American Idol 2008--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-25-08

[Shelayne]

Sheesh. I just cannot spell tonight.

Excellent NOT that other weird word I typed.

[silent_jonny]

I don’t get his obsession with Peggy when Min and Nancy are around. Peggy is such a know-it-all.

I think Bill just wants to live Hank's life--LOL :)

[MOgirl]

Hello,

LOL!!

:)

MOgirl

[Miss Didi]

I was over at MJ’s. Vote for the Worst calls Monchichi—WonderChimp.

[Miss Didi]

Which David?

[savedbygrace]

Exactly.

[silent_jonny]

Have you ever notice how whenever one of the contestants sang a pro-American song, Simon would comment that they made a very smart choice? I think that has happened at least a couple of times this season. I wonder what he would say about the choice syesha just made.

That's a very good point. Syesha just alienated all the red state voters. And this is primarily a red state show (I think Simon has acknowledged that in some of his interviews).

If Syesha had said this last night, Castro would be in the top 3 tonight.

[Wolfstar]

Bo has Crystal Gayle hair

Pretty photo of Crystal. Did she ever cut all that hair off?

[savedbygrace]

Dave, as Paula affectionately calls him. (rowr)

David Cook.

[silent_jonny]

One time silent_jonny and I were gossiping about something on FR and he said, “You know, the Peggy Hill types,” and I knew EXACTLY who he was talking about! LOL

I remember that :)

There aren't any Peggy Hill types on this thread though. At least, not on the ping list :)

[retrokitten]

Yeah, you are right. I think I just let my opinion of Peggy color everything.

[silent_jonny]

She’s sneaky....just like all dims. Used tears just like The Beast does...I want her gone! spit

The more I think about it, the madder I get.

Maybe because I liked her and wanted her to do well-- then she had to throw her politics in my face. And you're right, it was sneaky.

[retrokitten]

No there aren’t, thank God! LOL

[silent_jonny]

She might be able to sing but she is definitely not very savvy.

It definitely looked as if she was expecting a better reaction to her "change" comment than what she got.

[silent_jonny]

No wait - it looks like Greta Van Susteren.

HAHAHAHA!

[new cruelty]

I wonder if any of that registered with the producers of the show. I’ll look for any clarification from Ryan or even syesha next week.

[Miss Didi]

Wonder if anyone there in Hollywood land will even realize how mad the fans are.

[silent_jonny]

Totally Greta. Either before the eye job or after someone told her Scientology is made up and stupid.

ROFLMAO!

[Miss Didi]

We’ll never know if it hurt her because she would never be Top 2 anyway.

[silent_jonny]

I ventured over to another Idol forum and people are really steamed over Syesha’s “all-about-me, change, civil rights, presidential campaign” routine.

Good.