Watch out, they'd look at that line-up and probably blame it on Elmo....
EUREKA!! Gottleib is Mills Watson, the character actor of the 1970's and 80's. I saw him on a Rockford Files rerun the other day and said, "hmmmmmmm."
http://jartinmyhead.blogspot.com/2006/05/mills-watson-character-actor-of.html
"It was number 4 -- the guy sitting down in the middle--with the mustache and goatee."
LOL! - The paper made a huge understatement when they said Gottlieb fits that description best.
There's a reason they only printed his picture next to the stories right after the indcident. And he was the first to get a lawyer.