Here's my list.
1 Taylor Hicks - Great song choice for him and he performed it great.
2 Chris Daughtry - IMO A good idea to pick a song not many people know so his singing could speak for itself.
3 Katharine McPhee - Good voice and the song gave her the range to show it.
4 Elliott Yamin - Good but could have been better
5 Kellie Pickler - Looked like a freaking Zombie and hacked up the song. I know the have a time constraint but they F'ed up that song by cutting it all up.
6 Bucky Covington - Queen and country don't mix.
7 Paris Bennett - Bad night for her
8 Ace Young - Why is he still on the show?
A question we're all asking :)
I think Paris will be the one leaving tonight, though.