[A knight without armor]

I voted for Taylor Hicks. I thought he did the best last night. I did not like his clothes but his body looked different, tanner and thinner. Perhaps all this has put him outside more and he has lost weight? Or it is the make up artist.

Paris might have had the next best song. I don't know. I just cannot like her because to me she is such an overdone doll. She seems way too young to me.

I'm all for Mandisa proving to the world she can get up on the stage and be her best and not be super thin. Yet come on, I feel those jeans she wore last night were too homey and unflattering.

[Wolfstar]

I voted for Taylor Hicks. I thought he did the best last night.

He was the best last night. Maybe not by a mile, but definitely the best. I don't know how the judges could say that increasingly creepy McPhee was the best. Yuck!