Bo has much better charisma, that's for sure.
I think they both have amazing singing talent, but I lean towards Carrie because she just doesn't have as much access to opportunities in the music biz as Bo has had.
If Bo loses AI, someone will still sign him.
The reasons you edge toward her is exactly why I don't.
Bo has been working hard to get to where he is ready to be "now". She needs lots more grooming before she even gets to be a poor country western singer IMO. She is unmarketable for the most part IMO.
Her singing isn't THAT good either, whereas a year from now, we will be hearing a Bo hit single or two I am sure.
Bo is the most marketable guy of the last few years IMO.
He will make a record company and himself money.
Carrie won't do the same after the American Idol Tour is over IMO. She doesn't have "IT" IMO.
I agree with you about Carrie and Bo.