[kevkrom]

Your analysis is pretty good, but you missed the fact that Vonzelle was OFF KEY for all of both of her songs.

I didn't hear that. The first song certainly had its pitch problems, but I only noticed issues during transitions with the second song.

[freedumb2003]

Trust me, she was off (flat).

It seems a lot of people (read: Randy) can't hear when the singer is flat. He picks up on it when they go sharp, but not when the go flat.

Vonzelle tends to wander around the pitch rather than hit it. But that seems to be the tendancy for a lot of singers today. They tend to swoop up on the note because it is easier than hitting it.

I may despise her politics, but if you want to hear how to hit notes properly, listen closely to Babs.