I don't like the fact that Bo was arrested for drugs and Scott beat a women.I think making than an Idol sends a bad message to our youth,and they get enough bad messages daily.
Both Scott and Bo had bad things happen in their past.
But they've both "reformed" and are good examples of how boys who go bad can change their lives and make good of themselves.
I think they can show that it is possible and admirable to pick yourself up and make something out of your life after making some bad mistakes.
I respect both Scott and Bo a great deal for doing just that.
I think you might be a little (just a little) inflexible.
The real deal on Scott was that he had a fight (more like a tiff from what I have read) and got fwacked with a phone.
Bo's indescretion was standard fare for rockers -- and clearly he learned from his mistake.
Let's cut them a break.