I don't care about the dances anyway. Remember that dude (Travis I think) who was in the "top 10 guys?"
He was a dancer but couldn't sing to save his life. He was booted pretty early.
Carrie's not a disco dancer, but she can out-sing anyone in this remaining lot.
And as Simon says, it's a singing competition.
True, it is a singing competition, but thinking past this competition, even if she wins it, she has a better chance of making it really big if she has a bit more showmanship.
The kids that mostly go to those concerts like it active. Well, I do too and I'm 45.
I definitely think she's got the very best voice. Someone on another thread just now called AI the "Carrie Underwood Show".