Replies

She's probably the best candidate for a "pop" star out of the whole lot of them...

Yes, I think you're right about that. Of the eight left standing, the ones most likely to make it to the top 4 are Carrie, Bo, Constantine, and Vonzell. I don't know why she was in the bottom three this week, except perhaps that she and Nadia are splitting the same slice of the audience.

I think Vonzelle's problem this is week is that she chose such a difficult song, that many of the voting-age audience did not give her enough credit for how well she did it. I can't say that I have any liking for Streisand, but in her younger days, the gal could sing some seriously difficult stuff, and do it well. I just think it was too big of a chunk to chew off for only 6 days prep time.

Loved your review on FatAssia.

I think she must be taking a bottle of metimucial an hour prior to going on stage. It gives her the proper cramps to perform and she can "pass the problem" when she's off stage.

Ditto on the Vonzell/Nadia thing. It's just like last year with Jennifer/Latoya and FatAssia.
Nadia did better this week so the votes went to her. I personally thought Vonzell did great, but the judged "dissed" her and the votes swayed.

Someone else has my theory about the top 3. It will most likely be Carrie, Bo and Lt. Dan.
The votes will split between Bo and Constant-pain and Carrie will be on top. When they have the "Carrie vs. the Rocker" finals, the people who's "guy" lost will vote for Carrie just to "get back" at the other guy. That's how she wins it.
But if Vonzell can "steal" some votes from people voting for the "rockers" (go for the guys voting because she can look pretty hot if she wants too), it could spoil the above scenario and make things interesting.

One more thought...Simon picked Kelly, Ruben and FatAssia to win and he's picked Carrie this year. He's never lost.

I don't know why she was in the bottom three this week

I think she's boring. (Vonzelle) Someone may have a good voice, but that doesn't make them pop star material.

Out of the contenders left, the one's who I look forward to hearing or seeing are Nadia, because she's always interesting; Carrie, because her crystal clear pure voice actually moves me; Constantine, because nobody likes him and he's so in love with himself and shameless that he's fun to watch.

I don't turn on Idol excited to see what Vonzelle is going to do. She's just like an extra in a movie, to me.

I don't know why she was in the bottom three this week

I think she's boring. (Vonzelle) Someone may have a good voice, but that doesn't make them pop star material.

Out of the contenders left, the one's who I look forward to hearing or seeing are Nadia, because she's always interesting; Carrie, because her crystal clear pure voice actually moves me; Constantine, because nobody likes him and he's so in love with himself and shameless that he's fun to watch.

I don't turn on Idol excited to see what Vonzelle is going to do. She's just like an extra in a movie, to me.