I think she's boring. (Vonzelle) Someone may have a good voice, but that doesn't make them pop star material.
Out of the contenders left, the one's who I look forward to hearing or seeing are Nadia, because she's always interesting; Carrie, because her crystal clear pure voice actually moves me; Constantine, because nobody likes him and he's so in love with himself and shameless that he's fun to watch.
I don't turn on Idol excited to see what Vonzelle is going to do. She's just like an extra in a movie, to me.
All three of those are more appealing that the last two winners.
It's interesting this year, because no one seems to have both an excellent voice and well-developed performing skills. Carrie far and away has the best natural voice, as well as beauty. But her performance skills are underdeveloped.
Of the boys, I think Anthony is in the same boat as Carrie. A fine natural voice, although less advanced that Carrie, but no performance skills whatsoever. Simon has always been too harsh with Anthony, because Simon never liked Clay and unfairly sees Anthony as another Clay.
Constantine and Bo are good performers who know how to work the stage and the crowd. But both have so-so voices. Nadia is the same way. So-so voice, but she's a charming performer.
Anwar and Scott are also-rans, because both their voices and performance skills are weaker than the others, in my opinion.