American Idol 2005--Live Thread

3-15-05

[silent_jonny]

AMERICAN IDOL 2005
LIVE THREAD

[BamaDi]

I thought Nadia sucked tonight....and the hair has to go! Carrie is the one to beat....and I love the little girl at the end....she was great! but since i'm from Alabama, I'm rooting for Bo Bice also! Roll Tide

[BamaDi]

Josh Gracin.....#l country song lately...

and I love that - i liked him during season 2 - and simon absolutely couldn't stand him. simon doesn't like country music - just doesn't get it! i'm so happy for josh! I think carrie will go on to big things in Nashville!

[BamaDi]

no - simon's not being handsy with paula - she's been about to kiss him to death since the very beginning of the show! of course, if I were sitting next to him, I'd be doing the same thing! Simon's quite the hunk!

[Ciexyz]

I voted twice, for Bo and Nikko. I tried to vote for Anwar but his line kept ringing busy, so I got back on the Internet.

[BamaDi]

Michaela has to go tonight....until I heard her performance tonight I truly thought I was the worse singer on the planet....now, I'm not!!!! she was terrible!

[Ciexyz]

I've been watching "House". It's a relief from all the CSI shows and the ditzy comedies.

[Unknown Freeper]

Yes, House is a great show. I love his warped sense of humor. Intelligent humor/sarcasm. Plus you can learn a lot watching the show.

[I'm ALL Right!]

It's all about Carrie!!!!

She was fantastic tonight.

[silent_jonny]

Yes she was :-D I think she was better than everybody, including Bo, and that's saying something.

[stlnative]

Is there a House M.D. thread?

[Ciexyz]

Is there a House M.D. thread?

Talk to silent_jonny, he's involved with a number of Fox TV show threads.

[Ciexyz]

House is a very slick production. I'm enjoying it.

[The G Man]

Jessica messed up the lyrics of her song. She sang the verse:

"I don't know what to do and I'm always in the dark.
We're living in a powder keg and giving off sparks"

twice in a row. I was shocked the judges didn't say anything.

[The G Man]

Anybody else think Paula was under the influence tonight? From the kissing thing with Simon to the over the top dancing she was doing ... even during the commercial break they showed Simon and Randy immediately getting up leaving her alone at the table.

[EmilyGeiger]

I like Simon too! :) You sure do have good taste, must be because your from Alabama. :)

[Lijahsbubbe]

Reporting in, late.

I think Mikaela will be the one to go tomorrow. I think the weakest are: Mikaela, Scott and Constantine. They don't compare.

I don't think that Jessica is that great, either. How Simon could say she sang better than everyone else besides Carrie is B.S.

I don't think that Bo has a very good voice in comparison to those three, but I think he has a unique voice. But he's hard to look at.

For the women, I think Carrie is easily the most talented. Men, I would say Nikko.

[Wolfstar]

While I'm not a big fan of country music, I also like Josh very much. And I agree with you that Carrie will do well in Nashville no matter what happens on AI.

[over3Owithabrain]

My take on AI tonight:

Paula - shutup! Let someone else talk. And quit twitching around like you're in line at a meth clinic.

BO is da man. Whether he wins or not, he is gonna be big! He is the real deal, Constantine the pretender.

Wha' happened Nadia? Looked like she was fronting for Flock of Seagulls with that 'do. I love her and hope she survives that debacle and gets back on track next week.

Mikala - you're not Babs, or Bette, or even Fran. You're an annoying teenager. Enjoy your swan song tomorrow night.

Scott Savol - benefits from low expectations. Dude so fugly it's always a surprise to hear that cool voice coming out. Sooner or later he will fall though.

Carrie Underwood - great voice, pretty, humble. Her "Up With People" persona trumps her wooden stage presence. If she doesn't win, there's always Legally Blonde 3.

Best song choice - Total Eclipse. Worst song choice - Anwar doing Chaka Khan.

[silent_jonny]

Hi, I tried to ping you (twice) but I got an error message that FR didn't recognize your name. I typed "over30withabrain" exactly as you spell it, but no dice. Sorry for any inconvenience.

[silent_jonny]

Worst song choice - Anwar doing Chaka Khan.

I disagree. Lt. Dan singing that Partridge Family song--what could be worse than that?