American Idol 2005--Live Thread

3-15-05

[silent_jonny]

AMERICAN IDOL 2005
LIVE THREAD

[Wolfstar]

Yes, he fulfilled his obligations to the Marines, received his honorable discharge, then bought a house in Nashville and moved his family there. The thing about Josh is he's making it on his own without the AI machine. He took the time to finish his military obligation, even though it meant he couldn't take immediate advantage of the exposure he got on AI. He's still a new artist, and he as a way to go before really making it. But he's off to a good start.

[twin2]

David Cassidy is cringing...but he'll last another week.

[silent_jonny]

Simon called him a "poodle in a leather jacket" LOL.

[alisasny]

Josh did not go on the IDOL tour. I went with a friend in my area.....he was missed.

Rickie I believe sang his part in God Bless the USA on the tour.

[mystery-ak]

Nadia....what have you done?......what's happening tonight...

[silent_jonny]

David Cassidy is cringing

David Cassidy is looking forward to that royalty check.

Nadia's hair is so distracting, I can't hear the song.

[EmilyGeiger]

I was cringing too, crying, laughing, shuddering, so many words to describe it.

[Wolfstar]

My overall favorite is Kelly Clarkson, who is the #1 female pop artist in the country these days -- outselling even Jennifer Lopez's new CD. Kelly is working on her second double platinum CD, has two #1 songs on the Billboard charts, and has just released a new single.

I thought Clay should have won the 2nd season. And I think the right person, Fantasia, won last year.

[silent_jonny]

Simon says that was Nadia's weakest performance "by a mile". I agree.

[EmilyGeiger]

Yeah that was bad too. Cindy Lauper is hard to do because she is so unique.

[stlnative]

bookmarked

[alisasny]

Kelly is hoping that stupid movie vanishes..LOL

I actually cringe when I scan by it on TV.

[Wolfstar]

I didn't hear the National Anthem sung before last weekend's race, but heard a lot of negative comments about Montgomery's performance.

[mystery-ak]

I agree with Simon and you...I was too focused on her hair.....shame, cause I really like her...I hope she isn't voted off tomorrow..

[Wolfstar]

Josh did not go on the IDOL tour.

He went back on active duty with the Marines. Because he finished his military obligations and left with his honorable discharge, I wish Josh all the best in his music career. After AI, he probably could have found a way to get an early discharge, but he didn't. That makes him AOK in my book.

[silent_jonny]

Montgomery was terrible. I'm serious, the dude was drunk! He was singing and belching at the same time. The best part was when the military fly-over drowned him out.

[EmilyGeiger]

Was it as bad a Roseanne Arnold's performance.?

[Wolfstar]

Kelly is hoping that stupid movie vanishes..LOL

It was horrible. Justin Guarini's career tanked big time. But Kelly has something he doesn't -- real talent. She did Saturday Night Live recently and was wonderful.

[Unknown Freeper]

halfway through the song and mikalah hasn't hit a note yet.

[mystery-ak]

Mikalah....every dog in my neighborhood is wailing....