Fundamental Concepts

Human beings have two inherent qualities that quite impossible to ever eliminate "racism" entirely. Number one, we're tribal by nature. This is hard wired into our DNA, either by our creator or as a survival mechanism we inherited from our ancestors as we evolved. Why doesn't matter, but humans see things through the lens of "us" and "them" (I'm going to forgo quotes from here on out. Pixy doesn't like them and it's a pain to remove black diamonds). Us can be anything, it's an integral part of our self identity; my tribe, my family, my sports team, my nation, my club, my religion, my race, etc... Them is anyone who doesn't fit into whatever category is of paramount importance at the moment. There are various levels of usness and themness, and individual may be Them one second and Us the next. "That Johnson boy is a neighbor, but how dare he try to kiss my daughter, he's not one of us, I'll kill him!" * Barbarians attack * "Look out Johnson boy!" * Shoots barbarian about to impale JB on his spear * "Are you OK JB? Good, take this pistol and defend the house, I'm going after those sons of bitches." Us and Them is fluid and depends on context, but human beings categorize other humans without thought, slotting them into various Uses and Thems. We could no more stop it than we could breath water (waterbreathers. Ugh, I hate THEM).

The second thing working against us is that our primarily sense for experiencing the world is sight. We are visual creatures. In the context of racism based upon skin tone, combined with our automatic sorting of people into us and them, this is a double whammy. Color is, after simple light and dark (which makes vision possible in the first place), the first thing we notice. When the thing we notice is another person, as our subconscious mind starts it's us and them sort, color is going to have an outsized prominence in the equation.

So there you have it. Humans are physiologically hard wired to be, if not racist, at least race conscious. Does that mean we're doomed to living in a world that's always at least a little racist? Probably (the one scenario that I can think of that might change this is a species wide extinction level event, like an invasion by hostile aliens that forces humans to adopt an Us that means "human"). A bigger question is, does it matter? Maybe not.

As we've established, human beings are inherently racially conscious. I would argue that this isn't a positive trait. So what? Humans are inherently selfish, violent and mean as well. Those aren't positive traits either. What's important is how we act.

Don't tell the left, but you can't change people into something else. There is no New Soviet Man. All we have to work with is this flawed mortal clay. Here's where civilization comes into the picture. The purpose of civilization is to curb our baser human tendencies into something that's conducive to a functioning group of humans. People who can't control their violent tendencies are quarantined (jail) or eliminated. People who can't control their selfish nature are shunned. Mean people may be one or the other, depending on the circumstances. Why should racism be any different?

It's not, and nobody on the right that I've ever met thinks it is. Most of us realize that the United States today is a remarkably non-racist country, no matter what the MSM tries to tell you. We have succeeded in eliminating racism to a degree that I would argue hasn't been seen in the history of man. Institutional racism is dead. Societal racism is shunned to the point that it's taboo on par with incest. Individual racism? Well, it exists, but it's revealed in a very circumspect manner.

I was getting my hair cut in the local barbershop one day. I had just moved to the neighborhood, and my car had been broken into and the stereo stolen. I mentioned it to the barber (we're both white), and he said "It was probably some damn black kid who came up here from the city on the #3 (bus)". I didn't say anything, but I said to myself "This guy is a racist" and from then forward I tried to patronize other barbers in the shop. Then one day I saw something interesting. I was getting my hair cut by a different barber when a black woman came in with a couple of rowdy kids in tow. Here was a stereotype just made for disdain for a racist. She was fat, her kids were urban and belligerent, they were obviously lower class urban, likely from different fathers (there were three kids and their skin tone varied a lot. I know that doesn't mean anything, but that's my observation, my filtering of Us and Them). What did the "racist" barber do? He greeted her professionally with a smile, bantered a bit, took the kids one at a time into his chair and gave them excellent haircuts. He thanked them for coming in, and asked them to come back again soon, even when they didn't tip. (I made an excuse to hang out just to see how it all played out).

Well. Here's a conundrum. A man I had tagged as racist because of his statement had just acted in a decidedly non-racist fashion. He revealed his racist thoughts to me because he tagged me as part of his Us, but then when a time came where he might act upon those thoughts, he didn't. He didn't treat his customers as Them.

Honestly, what more can society ask? Think or believe what you will. Say what you want (within limits). How you act....that's where the rubber meets the road. You could be as racist at Woodrow Wilson, but if it doesn't affect how you treat people, so what? To my mind, and I think to most conservatives, that's the reality of racism.

Lets just review for a minute. Racism is a universal human trait. It is also nearly universally condemned by society. These two forces are in opposition to each other. Because of that, an accusation of racism is a powerful weapon. It's also a weapon that is only effective against people who recognize that racism is bad and want to be non-racist. Think about it. Accuse the grand Keegle (or Klaven or Klegel or Klown, whatever he calls himself) of the KKK of racism. He'll look at you like you're nuts. "Of course I am, do you see the robe? Do you see the hood?". He'll then give you chapter and verse why he thinks racism is good. Dig up Adolf Hitler, reanimate him and mention that you have some concerns about the way he treats Jews. He'll tell you Duh, I wrote a whole book about it. ACTUAL RACISTS ARE PROUD OF BEING RACIST. You and I? That's a different story.

Suppose someone accused you of rape. You know rape is a thing, a vile thing, and you've just been accused of doing it. You're going to defend yourself. Same thing with murder. Same thing with racism. You instinctively react in defensive mode, and by doing so you give the accusation a validity that it doesn't deserve. The focus shifts from the facts to your denial.

That's the nub of it. Accusations of racism in America today are almost always attempts to shut down an honest discussion of the facts. Zimmerman wasn't attacked by Martin, he was a racist. Brown didn't attack Wilson, Wilson killed Brown because he is a racist. Antonio Martin didn't point a Hi-Point 9MM at a cop and get killed for his trouble, it's racism. And so on, and so on, and so on.

It's not going to stop. As we've seen, racism is inherent in all of us, it's evil, and no matter how hard we try as a society and a people to suppress it, when something happens that can even remotely be classified as racist, no matter the facts, it's going to be framed that way. Why? Because it puts non-racists on the defensive and defangs their arguments.

It's damn brilliant. Every single one of you reading this is going to have to pee in the next 24 hours. If I can somehow convince you that you need to apologize for peeing, why, I've got a lot of power over you, don't I?

Most conservatives are concerned with how an individual acts. Think what you want, I don't care, I care what you do. Liberals care about how one thinks and feels. You say welfare state has destroyed the black family? Who cares, I support it because it makes me feel good about myself. I'm doing good! Look at me everyone, I'm good!

"Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet." Once again Kipling nails it.

We are divided by tribalistic assignments of “us,” and “them”. ...but there are variances as to how one becomes part of each category.

“German” is racial combined with national. “American” is conceptual.

I think we need to work to understand ourselves better. Humanity is strong because we are adaptable, and because we are adaptable we will have differences, there is nothing wrong with that. We should be more respectful and learn to play to our strengths, adaptation is one of those strengths.

To deny an asset, and the flexibility of humanity to be able to exist almost anywhere on earth is a huge asset, is to do us all disrespect and disservice. It might make the accounting easier to say we are all interchangeable units of human capital, but thats lazy wishful thinking contrived by some philistine who is missing the point that we are capable of so much more than being cogs in someone’s machine.

"This is hard wired into our DNA"

I disagree. We learn racism. We don't know it as children.

As a child born in 1950, I grew up with 2 racist parents. Still, I tried to ignore it. We lived in an area of Los Angeles that had whites, blacks, hispanics, and asians within a few miles of my house. My best friend in grammar school was Japanese, but eventually I succumbed due to the Watts riots.

However, when I joined the Navy, I quickly left that behind and only saw my shipmates. I had a wonderful black friend that I hung out with. Had to think for a moment for an example since I saw no color during those days.

Unfortunately, I'm becoming bigoted again after watching the racist reactions to the Trayvon Martin/Ferguson/Garner incidents. Not to mention the black on black atrocities committed every day in Detroit, Chicago, Philly, et al. The blacks and their self-appointed leaders are bringing this upon themselves. I hate them for doing this to me.

Disclaimer: There are still many exemplary blacks that I admire.

I think that political correctness has gone well beyond getting everyone to give each other a fair shot and well into the unhelpful realm of letting people accuse one another of the vilest of motivations and letting such speculation stand as fact. We do have historical precedent, the witch hunts.

People who care about the continuity of their heritage, community, nation, tribe or what have you, need to understand that it is not wrong in any sense to understand that all human progress that is capable of being retained and amplified, involves multi-generational efforts & concepts. Calling them "racist," is neither rational nor appropriate.

"Racism"--that is as something that should be condemned--should be confined to a description of behavior that treats others unkindly, simply because they are different. When you extend the definition to include those who simply take pride in their lines of descent; or those who seek to pass on their achievements to their posterity (as did the Founding Fathers in the Constitution), you shackle yourself with a self-defeating mantra, that wars on all that is constructive in social formations.

William Flax

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.