[RummyChick]

Oh really????

Find it in any of these cases:

Reynolds v. United States
Wilkerson v. Utah

Kilbourn v. Thompson
Same court.

If her citizenship was GERMANE to this case you would have have a discussion of her parents citizenship.

You want to see the difference??

Flores -Villar was a citizenship case.
Scotus discussed Nguyen in that case. This time oral arguments didn’t breath a word about NBC.

But as for citizenship - look at the difference between this when it is germane and Minor WHEN IT WAS NOT.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/09-5801

Minor was a VOTING case NOT a citizenship case.

[BuckeyeTexan]

We're not discussing those cases. We're discussing MvH. I've shown you the Court's declaration that the question before the Court included the plaintiff's assertion that Minor was a citizen and the Court's declaration that it had to affirm Minor's citizenship before it could address her right to vote. If you still don't get that Minor's citizenship was not mentioned in passing, then I can't help you.