Obama's aunt angry at Trump (Now she claims family got letter from BHO Sr. in Hawaii)

WHDH-TV / CNN ^ | April 11, 2011

[2ndDivisionVet]

BOSTON - Barack Obama's aunt, Zeituni Onyango, says Donald Trump disrespected her family by questioning the president's birthplace.

Trump quoted Obama's grandmother when she claimed to have witnessed Barack Obama's birth in Kenya, and Onyango says that is not true.....

[David]

And yet, we are shown a number of images which supposedly were taken from a MIHS yearbook, if you GOOGLE IMAGES - Stanley Ann Dunham - you will find a number of them...so someone must have had a BOOK when this article was written, IN 2008:

From the Times Article: "In 1960, Stanley Ann Dunham graduates from Mercer Island High School."

I don't see the 2008 date on the article but I will take your word for it.

But as I am sure you recognize, there is a huge hole in that story you can drive a moving van through--and that may be what someone is refering to above when they say look at the book before 1961 and the book after 1961--I don't know why you would look at the book afterward.

However if the Times has the correct date, it fits together a number of the events and dates on the timeline. I think we have a fix on her earlier education class schedule so you need to take a year out of that somewhere but lots of other events then line up with the dateline.

I assume the Times is incorrect. But if they are not, you move Stanley Ann back one year and everything else fits--except that you might have some trouble making Senior the father of a kid born in January 1961.

[David]

MY NUMBER 881 IS A BOOT--1960 WAS THE CORRECT DATE:

"But as I am sure you recognize, there is a huge hole in that story you can drive a moving van through--and that may be what someone is refering to above when they say look at the book before 1961 and the book after 1961--I don't know why you would look at the book afterward.

However if the Times has the correct date . . . . I assume the Times is incorrect."

[Fred Nerks]

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/politics/2004334057_obama08m.html

Originally published April 8, 2008 at 12:00 AM | Page modified April 8, 2008 at 12:50 PM

Caption:Stanley Ann Dunham, Barack Obama’s mother, in the 1959 Mercer Island High School yearbook. She died of ovarian cancer in 1995

Question: Who supplied the image? Can we know if the caption is correct, without seeing the image on an ACTUAL PAGE of the yearbook?

[David]

“Now, the above doesn’t mean that Obama was born somewhere other than Hawaii. It’s just further evidence that those who claim that we know all there is to know are lying and, in the case of Wikipedia, are actively trying to silence debate.”

The August 19 date on that chart is incorrect—there is now a letter above from the University on this thread confirming that the correct date is September 19.

[Fred Nerks]

...The August 19 date on that chart is incorrect—there is now a letter above from the University on this thread confirming that the correct date is September 19.

Not so fast...they blamed the 'mistake' on an employee...who transcribed the wrong date. TWICE. Well, 'they' would, wouldn't they? After presenting something clearly impossible, as their own 1961 calendar shows semester commencement as September 25, 'they' had to blame the typist. And the correction they made was SEPTEMBER 19. Still WRONG. Wrong by only six days, but STILL WRONG. All 'they' changed was an 8 into a 9. I am still not convinced there isn't some skullduggery going on.

[little jeremiah]

Even if nothing else had been found by the researchers (which it has) just the very fact that everyone in this “narrative” is an enigma with pulled articles, scrubbed documents, hidden evidence, missing years, discrepancies right and left - would prove standing alone that something is terribly rotten.

What to speak of actual evidence of a whole ‘nother actual history.

[bgill]

Yes, that video has been out a while but what I’m asking is if you don’t have a year book in your hands then you can’t say it is there or not. Has a FReeper been to Mercer Island in person to knock on doors and talk to classmates (or wherever they may be now days) and their now elderly parents to see a year book? No. It takes leg work, not internet work or phone or email work. Face to face is what it is going to take to prove anything one way or the other. Most of those year books, friends pictures, and newspaper articles are in the parents’ attics and all it takes is one lonely parent to jump at the chance to tell tales of sonny boy and his classmates.

[bgill]

Several of the Obama File links are old and scrubbed. Glad he leaves them there just so we know that at one time the info was out there.

[GregNH]

The lighting seems to be casting a shadow behind and to her left side. Would we not see the same effect from the girl in the front and the girl to SAD'd right? I don't have a photo software but maybe someone has already examined that.

[Brown Deer]

You have consistently shown that you have absolutely no ability to read.

You have consistently shown that you are a complete moron.

[Brown Deer]

there is now a letter above from the University on this thread confirming claiming that the correct date is September 19.

[bgill]

Very good. Either it’s been packed back in a dark corner of the parents’ attic or it’s long been tossed out. Memories fade so stating SADO came to see someone on X date is a stretch. And remember, one person’s perception of an event is not the same as another’s.

[Fred Nerks]

START WITH THE INDEX PAGE:

http://theobamafile.com/index.htm

I don’t think anything has been ‘scrubbed’ maybe revised, and you linked to an old Google page.

[Fred Nerks]

Point taken, but please address that to anyone who might live in that area, bit hard for me, I am in AUSTRALIA.

[bgill]

In my family, the grown grandkids (my generation) are all taller than our grandparents and our kids are taller than us. That’s usually the case these days. People are getting taller what with better nutrition and medical care.

[little jeremiah]

I think that may have been the case a few generations ago but I really don’t think people now have better nutrition than the mid 20th century.

[Natural Born 54]

The fake pearls photo has this caption: Courtesy Mercer Island High School Yearbook. I guess nobody wanted credit for that one, not even Tony Nugent.

The other photo, given its source, would have had to come from the 1958 yearbook. In my opinion, 1958 was the first year a yearbook was published. That makes SAD a 10th grader in that photo if she was indeed in the class of 1960.

Her birthday being in Nov., btw, would have put her in the class of 1961 in most school districts - then and now. In the 1958 year book you would find class of ‘58, ‘59 and ‘60 (MIHS was a 3 year high school for quite some time after it opened in ‘55 and did not have 9th graders.)

If SAD wasn’t placed ahead one year somewhere along the line, then she would not have been in Tony Nugent’s 1958 yearbook. Of course that would have created a major problem - it wouldn’t have allowed for the Hawaii conception of Barry Obama and his subsequent birth in Aug. of 1961, would it?

[bgill]

Pictures state, “Courtesy Tony Nugent” so he should have a yearbook. Where is he and is there a FReeper who lives close enough to him to go see for themselves?

[Natural Born 54]

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/bloggers/2702976/posts?page=732#732

[bgill]

Plus, the "documentary proof" of a marriage between Stanley and Obama has never been exhibited in a court of law, provenance clear, with the person bringing said document under oath.

Again, HI is hiding something. Go to any other courthouse in the US and you can look at the original record books and not some digital index as proof.