Posted on 09/09/2015 7:56:29 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson knocked rival Donald Trump's immigration plan on Tuesday, saying that deporting the country's undocumented immigrants "sounds really cool" but would be far too costly and complicated.
"It sounds really cool, you know, 'Let's just round them all up and send them back,'" Carson said. "People who say that have no idea what that would entail in terms of our legal system, the costs - forget about it. Plus, where you gonna send them? It's just a double whammy."
Carson has been gaining on Trump, the GOP frontrunner, in recent polls. An NBC/Marist poll released Sunday found Carson has jumped to second place in Iowa among Republican voters, seven points behind the real estate mogul.
Trump's immigration plan calls for deporting the estimated 11 million undocumented workers currently in the U.S., a proposal that opponents say would cost billions and would be nearly impossible to execute. Carson said that he instead favors a plan that would allow undocumented workers the chance to become guest workers.
he outspoken leader of the GOP field has so far refrained from knocking Carson, though that could soon change if the former neurosurgeon continues his steady rise in the polls.
"I'm hoping for Ben to really hit me at some point because I love to counter-punch," Trump said on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" last week.
(Excerpt) Read more at nbcnews.com ...
“That’s an “if” on the scale of stellar distances, and stellar masses. “
I agree. Therein lies the problem.
He is a good man. He’s also a doctor - and he cares about people being safe. It’s one of his strong points... and one of his weak points.
True.
And Ike was more concerned about Americans than about Mexicans. It’s a message Jeb! doesn’t get... it’s not all about pity parties... some of the job is protecting American citizens...
It does not have to be that way. They could remain here as second class citizens without the benefits and without voting privileges. There are lots of options. Problem is, everyone gets emotional and knee jerk about it.
Fester. You're not being realistic. You talk almost as if you have never lived in the US and don't know any liberals and have never read the New York Times.
Things don't work that way here. If they are here, they are going to get everything. You should know that.
In certain places there are no doubt challenges. But we bored tunnels through mountains, went to the moon and laid cable across the oceans. Challenges far greater than a mere wall no matter said wall’s complexity. It’s simply a $$$/Will issue.
Now if there is some area with a huge cliff or something that is a natural wall, then no, no need to build one atop it. Just incorp it to the design. Any wall will have to be patrolled/monitored regardless.
In all seriousness, and for all my belief in ‘Wall’, I openly accept that this ‘could’ all be done with tech and no wall at all.. But that runs smack dab into the big and perhaps biggest issue which I mentioned before.
The wall IMO is not so much in my mind to stop Illegals directly, although it would do that well. It is to stop liberals.
When St. Ronaldus err’d so badly, the ink was not yet dry on the Amnesty before liberals began gutting everything about it that protected America. Smart fencing can be turned off at the flick of a USCC court order. Hell some regional Fed has bastardized all manner of laws in that way.
As we saw twice now with National guard troops, they are sent as a feelgood measure and put in offices miles from the actual border, unarmed and given papers to push. Without a wall, they merely get told ‘stand down’. and they must obey.
Now if you COMBINE all the points you made...the fines/jail etc for employers, take away the bennies etc. WITH a physical wall, you get self deporting illegals with NO EASY WAY to get back in any significant number, massively curtailed drug/crime flow and most importantly, no easy way for liberals to dismantle it/the whole shebang without massively POing a LOT of voters.
It’s one thing for Barry to spend 6Bil in Iraq/Afghan/Syria every third day. No one sees it. That money, real though it is, has no substance to Americans. It’s a number the news reports like a million others.
It is quite another to have a wall instantly ending half out related issues before it is even finished and than having Barry’s next of commie kin convince someone that the thing they SEE they spent 6Bil on has gotta be removed at a 50 Bil cost.
Not gonna fly.
Now we have Isis in South America headed north eventually and in number thanks to the refugee crap. A wall works for Israel. It will work for us too. We just need to build it. And we can.
Realism does not have to accept the status quo, nor need it propose draconian measures.
Fair enough.
Ok, Fester. I guess you’re not interested in a discussion.
Here is an interesting article on how well Dr. Carson has done with only a fraction of the money used by Trump or a number of other candidates.
I'm impressed with the quiet goodness of Ben Carson... we're blessed he's on our team.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.