Deport Children of Illegals: Hunter

NBC ^ | 4/28/10 | staff

[UCFRoadWarrior]

Duncan Hunter for President. No more RINOs.....

Someone with leadership...not bi-partisianship

[Retired COB]

RINO - like Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio, McCain, Meg Whitman, et al.

You're at least one half right.

[Vermont Lt]

OK, here is what I found on a very quick search:

In the case of United States v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649 (1898), the Supreme Court ruled that a person becomes a citizen of the United States at the time of birth, by virtue of the first clause of the 14th amendment of the Constitution, if that person is:

Born in the United States

Has parents that are subjects of a foreign power, but not in any diplomatic or official capacity of that foreign power

Has parents that have permanent domicile and residence in the United States

Has parents that are in the United States for business

---

I apologize for thinking it was in the constitution. I’ve read the damn thing so many times, you’d think I would have known it wasn’t addressed directly. I wonder why it isn’t? It seems like something they would have thought about before talking about everything else. Sort of, “here’s who can be in the club” before defining the club rules.

I stand corrected and humbled once more....

[Retired COB]

And a constitutional amendment is required to change that.

All they have to do is change back to the original meaning.....something about persons subject to the jursidiction of the United States. That's why the childred of foreign diplomats are not given US citizenship - they are foreign citizens and not subject to our laws.

[HiJinx]

Ping!

[Retired COB]

childred

Equals children

[2dogjoe]

“Hunter...said he does not BELIEVE children born to illegal immigrant parents should get automatic U.S. citizenship. “

It doesn’t matter what Hunter believes. It is current law.

You cannot deport the American citizen children of illegal aliens.

He needs to help change the law.

[Altura Ct.]

Right on Mr Hunter!

[Issaquahking]

This is what Mark Levin says in Liberty and Tyranny" And I agree 110% with him.


The Statist tolerates the illegal alein’s violations of working wage, and environmental standards, because of the alien’s babies born in Amrica are, under the “current interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, treated as United States citizens. And under the Hart – Cellar Act, upon turning twenty-one years of age, the child can sponsor additional family memembers for citizenship. From the Statist’s perspective, the pool of future of future administrative state constituents and sympathetic voters is potentially bottomless.

But does the Fourteenth Amendment grant automatic citizenship to the children of illegal aliens? The relavent part of the amendment reads that “all persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, ar citizens of the United States.” The language requires more than birth within the United States. The amendment’s purpose was to grant citizenship to the emancipated slaves, who were born in the United States and owed sole allgiance to it. Native Americans who were also subject to tribal jurisdiction were excluded from citizenship. There is no legislative history supporting the absurd propostion that the Fourteenth Amendment was intended to empower illegal alien parents to confer American citizenship on their own babies merely as a result of their birth in the United States. Foreign visitors and diplomats are not subject to the jurisdiction of their home country, as are their children, wheter they are born in their home country or the United States.


I agree with Mr Levin that the BS of allowing "chain migration" was never the intent of the Founding fathers.

[highlander_UW]

That is interesting.

[Nea Wood]

If someone robs a bank or commits some other crime, we send him to prison. That separates him from his children. It’s sad, but it’s the parent’s fault for committing the crime. We are under no obligation to “keep parents and children together” when the parent has freely chosen to violate our laws.

[Hodar]

That was very good .... interesting and thought provoking! Thanks.

[ZULU]

I agree.

If he is like his father, he is a Great American.

[Issaquahking]

You bet, Mark is "The great one!" Forces people to open their eyes, and see what has already been said (Liberty and Tyranny), makes him a good listen too:)

[2dogjoe]

Pissant,

Your comments using terms like “Aunt Chalupa”, “Tio Borracho” and “Frijole” depress me as a proud member of this great organizaion named Free Republic.

I don’t want to believe that you, as a fellow Freeper, are a rascist.

Comments like yours and from other individuals like you all over this great country, disparage us Conservatives.

There is no need for such language to make a point. You lower yourself to the emotional and immature level of the opposition when you speak with that kind of language.

Pissant, may you have a blessed day.

Twodog

[Regulator]

They aren't citizens.

The illegals don't decide for us who our citizenry will be.

End of story. They go home.

[WOBBLY BOB]

The Great One ping...

[pissant]

I can’t please all the hundreds of PC grievance mongers, so I don’t bother even trying.

Let me guess, a chihuahua that Quiere Taco Bell is racist too.

PS: I’m 1/2 mezcan.

[pissant]

He has been trying to change the ‘law’, but actually, it really IS NOT THE LAW, it is only being misinterpreted by a bunch of pansy ass clowns.

[AuntB]

“‘You’re a mean guy, that’s a mean thing to do, that’s not a humanitarian thing to do.’ We simply cannot afford what we’re doing right now,” he said. “California’s going under.””

BTTT!!!! Finally! Let me remind the soft hearted/headed, that our servicemen are separated from their children ALL the time...they don’t even get the choice to take them with them. And our servicemen are housed much harsher than the illegal aliens detention centers.

Here’s how you do it.

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2401786/posts?page=12#12

The Terry Anderson Show 90 Day
Invasion Solution Without Confusion

http://www.theterryandersonshow.com/