Posted on 01/31/2008 12:18:57 PM PST by BradtotheBone
WASHINGTON — Senate Democrats said today they would force votes next week on adding rebates for senior citizens and disabled veterans and heating aid for the poor to the House-passed economic stimulus package.
The move marked a lapse in the broad bipartisan cooperation that sped the stimulus plan through the House, and set the stage for a contentious fight between Republicans who are balking at adding to the bill and Democrats who believe it should be larger.
"Democrats have spoken on how this package can be improved," said Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev.
He said the measure was still on track for completion by Feb. 15. "We are doing this as fast as we can," he said.
But Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said the proposed add-ons were slowing down rebate checks for millions of Americans, now expected to be delivered starting in May.
"The stimulus train is grinding to a halt here in the U.S. Senate," McConnell said.
Under Reid's plan for Senate action on the stimulus package, the Senate could vote as early as Monday on a bill that would tack $32 billion onto the House measure with rebates of $500-$1,000 to all but the richest taxpayers, with more for families with children.
Approved by the Finance Committee on Wednesday with just three Republican votes, the package also would expand rebate eligibility to 20 million older Americans on Social Security and to disabled veterans, and it would provide an unemployment extension for those whose benefits have run out.
The Senate measure would pump $193 billion into the economy over the next two years, compared with the $161 billion House measure that would send $600-$1,200 rebates to a narrower group.
Democrats in the Senate don't expect to be able to muster the 60 votes they would need to pass the measure, so they will follow up with efforts to add their favorite items — including jobless benefits, food stamps and heating aid for the poor and housing relief — to the House bill, Reid said.
They also plan to hold separate votes on adding heating aid and rebates for seniors and disabled veterans, which would pose a sticky dilemma for Republicans facing re-election.
"It's tough votes for them," said Sen. Charles E. Schumer of New York, who heads the Democrats' Senate campaign arm.
If none of their proposals attracts enough backing to win approval, the Senate will pass the House measure, Reid said.
The bill approved by the Finance Committee would extend unemployment payments for 13 weeks for those whose benefits have run out, with 26 more weeks available in states with the highest unemployment rates. The only state that currently meets the trigger is Michigan.
Labor unions are pressing hard for the extension. The AFL-CIO circulated a letter to senators Thursday urging them to include it in the final stimulus bill.
Democrats said it would be difficult for senators to oppose sending rebate checks to seniors, who also have been lobbying intensively to be included in the stimulus bill.
The Senate measure would deliver flat rebates of $500 for individuals and $1,000 for couples to anyone earning at least $3,000, with income limits of $150,000 for individuals and $300,000 for couples. The rebate would phase out for those making more, disappearing altogether for individuals with income of $160,000 for individuals and $320,000 for couples. The caps would be higher for those with children.
It also goes farther than the House package in efforts to bar illegal immigrants from receiving rebates. Under the Senate measure, recipients and their spouses and children would need valid Social Security numbers to qualify. The House bill omits that requirement, although it expressly disqualifies nonresident aliens.
Today, House leaders indicated they would move to clarify a provision in their version of the bill to stipulate that no rebates could go to illegal immigrants.
"We will take legislative action to clarify and underscore this prohibition so we can expedite the rebates to millions of eligible Americans," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Republican Leader John A. Boehner of Ohio, said in a joint statement.
The Senate plan would restore a business tax break dropped during the House negotiations that would permit corporations suffering losses now to reclaim taxes previously paid.
Both packages include roughly $50 billion worth of tax incentives for businesses to invest in new plants and equipment.
By the time they get done with it it will just be another entitlement program and not a dime will go back to anyone that actually paid some taxes.
Shows how much faith I have in any of them doesn’t it?
The Repub plan had a lower income ceiling.
My guess is that the Dems know the richer ones won't spend the $ but will either save or invest it.
They are tricky...they are coming across as generous with this plan but they are bloating the payout here with funds that won't even stimulate the economy.
The Dems' plan with this stimulus is actually to slow down the economy not stimulate it.
This will stimulate the economy like taking a bucket of water from the deep end of a pool and pouring it into the shallow end will make the shallow end get deeper.
Isn’t it just an advance on next year’s refund?
I sure as hell want to know who would deny economic assistance to senior citizens.
Let’s big ball and go for $2 million! Oh, yeah, and some money for my heating bills. I’ve got the windows open right now and the government’s got to make me whole.
A day or two? Hell, there should be a drop box for your return and yearly check right in front of the voting booth....
I think this needs to go into committee for at least two years to make sure it is well thought out!
/s
“So why not just give the people what they want and need, hell the men behind the curtain get theirs the same way and don’t do a damn thing.”
But ‘their’ money would have no ‘wealth’ if everyone was rich.
The ‘rich’ would not exist without the ‘poor’.
Someone has to run the machines that keep the castles afloat on top of the clouds, and someone has to empty the trash.
If everyone is rich, no castles floating, and trash everywhere.
I can see Pelosi standing next to the Soup Nazi (dressed as Uncle Sam) saying “NO CHECK FOR YOU....1 YEAR...NO, 5 YEAR!”
AND, the net amount paid to the gov’t needs to be POSITIVE before you can cast your vote.
“...but they are bloating the payout here with funds that won’t even stimulate the economy.”
Yeah, I was wondering how stimulating food stamps would be.
May God bless you for your great support of this nation,btw.:D
Bush has already said he will veto anything that comes to him that is different from what was originally agreed upon. Not that I’m in favor of this ‘stimulus package’, but clearly the libs are just using it as a political weapon instead of actually wanting to do anything to help the economy.
I'm with you. I grew up dirt poor and have busted my arse for the past 35 years for the priviledge to earn too much. I don't get crap in this deal and I am pissed.
“Isn’t it just an advance on next year’s refund?”
Shhhhhhh.......!
You might make people ‘think’ about the future, and how hard it might be to have a very small rebate come tax time a year from now.
That is because the only “economic solution” they are familiar with is raising taxes, and wealth redistribution... Neither of which benefit the economy, no matter how one spins it.
I weep for our Republic, or what little is left of it...
I don’t have kids at home but do have seven dogs and cats. They eat more than the kids used to. Where’s my animal rebate??
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.