Replies

Sorry, but the us against them mentality is promoted just as much if not more by the NO crowd here. It is a huge turnoff.

I've been watching for quite a while now and the side which makes the most consistent, most reasonable arguments are the traditionalists. This article is just one more in the line I've found exploring this side.

This division twixt trads and neo-cons is the work of Satan. The Liturgy ought never have been permitted to have undergone such radical changes without continuing the 1962 Roman Missal as an option for those who desired to worship as did their Fathers and Grandfathers and Great Grandfathers.

The Church IS big enough for us to fight the doctrinal battles WITHIN the Body of Christ without either of the syblings forcing the other to leave the house. What the hell kind of a family is it that never fights over matters of life and death?

Dominicans and Franciscans disagreed on Grace yet both remained within the house of the Family of God. (So what if the Molinists were wrong?)

Basta.

Neo-Cons and Trads are Catholics.

I have yet to see either a Trad or a Neo profess heresy since I have been reading these threads.

The Pope COULD settle this in a heartbeat. He has the authority.

I've been watching for quite a while now and the side which makes the most consistent, most reasonable arguments are the traditionalists.

Really? They're all anti-John Paul II.

Is that reasonable to you?