Around the DC area, going from door to door is out this year. The kids will be going to a party in costumes, play some games such as pin-the-tail-on-the-donkey (we'll wait for Dashwood to tell us about the Satanic signifigance of that!), and get some goodies to take home. Yeah, sounds like an evening dedicated to the worship of all that is unholy to me.
I shall simply observe that a braying jackass is the self-chosen symbol of the Democratic Party, and leave other to consider the possible satanic significance of your proposed game.