Did I convert you?
<> No. I was describing as errors those unauthorised things introduced into the Liturgy.
When one strives to remove unauthorised actions, additions etc, one is not reforming a reform, one is correcting errors - errors for which Pope John Paul II apologised in an Encyclical.
I know the phrase "reform of the reform" has a certain memetic quality to it but, imo, it misses the mark as it appearts to be the case that what the R of R" is focused on are unauthorised additions to the Liturgy not the authentic reform qua reform.<>