I apologize for any confusion. I guess I should spending more time reading!!!!!!! :-)
Sock, you said,
***Now, instead of straining at knats maybe you (PhD ?) can refute the article? Or is that just it? You cant refute it so you look for the knats?***
What are knats?. In Baton Rouge we have Gnats; however it's the mosquitos around here that need restraining at present. Know what I mean?
I also noted in your post the question mark after the PhD, sounds like you are skeptical.
I'm still trying to determine whether the article needs refutation. However, I do appreciate your interruption of what had been a cordial discussion.