[Gophack]

I apologize for the misunderstanding. He said he wasn't arguing from the Catholic or the Protestant perspective, and his conclusion is definitely not the Catholic position (which leaves the question on the authenticity of the DC's open). I thought that the information on the historical background interesting, and thought RN would as well.

I apologize for any confusion. I guess I should spending more time reading!!!!!!! :-)

[drstevej]

No problem, Gophack. In looking at the site he appeaars to he a bit ecclectic.

Sock, you said,

***Now, instead of straining at knats maybe you (PhD ?) can refute the article? Or is that just it? You can’t refute it so you look for the knats?***

What are knats?. In Baton Rouge we have Gnats; however it's the mosquitos around here that need restraining at present. Know what I mean?

I also noted in your post the question mark after the PhD, sounds like you are skeptical.

I'm still trying to determine whether the article needs refutation. However, I do appreciate your interruption of what had been a cordial discussion.