I've stayed out of this cat fight, but it's been fun to watch.
ultima, you have been asked, over and over and over, to back up your contention that the SSPX sect is "flourishing." Your word is not enough. You've got to back up what you say with citations, or, clearly state that what you are saying is your opinion.
And, the Catholic Church continues to grow, year after year. The Catholic Church in America now stands 62 million, from 40 million in 1980.
A coworker of mine converted to Catholicism on Easter Sunday 2001. His wife was already Catholic. They have 3 children, all baptized in the Catholic faith. He just happened to mention to me this week that they went to Mass this past weekend for the first time since Easter of this year.
So much for your headcount of Catholic Church in America (Amchurch). Give us a true headcount of practicing Catholics; your numbers will be pathetic.