Replies

But for arguements sake, let's presume you are correct and I am a schismatic

The SSPX Bishops were excommunicated, and JPII called it a schism. Whether you are personally schismatic or not I’ll leave to the Church to work out, but the Church has spoken about your Bishops and the Society.

It has said they are schismatic.

According to the Holy Father John Paul II, there are many paths to Heaven

Actually the Holy Father has not said that. Jesus Christ is the only path.

and our "seperated bretheran" are able to share in the fruits of Christ's redemptive act. So what have I to lose by trying my best to follow the teaching of Christ, the saints, many Popes and doctors of the Church?

The separated brethren can get there through a level of invincible ignorance, but even then their odds would be much better if they were to reside in the bosom of the Church.

You, fully knowing the Pope to be God’s representative on earth, do not have the luxury of invincible ignorance. You have the faith, should you leave it it is your choice. You are not a Protestant, don’t act like one.

You can have at least some of the Sacramental Grace in the SSPX, the liturgy is valid of course. But if you are schismatic, you recognize that, as Aquinas said, schism is a sin against charity. Sins separate us from God, especially one this serious. Were it me, this would be a cause for concern. That is what you have to lose.

You can’t claim you are doing your best to follow the teachings of “many Popes and doctors of the Church” and then proceed to ignore - in part or in whole - the Pope placed over you today. The Church is not a dead organism, as so many Protestants would have us believe. Its teaching authority did not end after Trent or Vatican I. To believe this is similar to believing that its teaching authority ended after the Apostles died, as most Protestants believe.

Vatican I also made it clear you have to do more than obey the infallible pronouncements. The Pope has ultimate jurisdiction, and a Catholic is subject to that. If you are not subject to that authority, you are schismatic, and that authority states you can’t properly attend a Society Mass.

Dominus Vobiscum

patent +AMDG