"I concede your ultimate point. I hope that my brothers here will see that same point and withdraw their claims that the SSPX is heretical."
I agree with you. It seems to me that it is Peter himself who is working to try to bring the SSPX back into full communion, and it seems to me that it is Peter himself who regards the SSPX as schismatic, and not heretical. Otherwise, the talks toward reunion would not be about things like Apostolic Administrations and such.
That notwithstanding, some SSPXers, even at high levels in their hierarchy, seem to be materially heretical.
sitetest