It's troubling.
Finally! I was wondering when the anti-Semitic accusation train would roll in. I haven't seen an eschatalogical debate yet that didn't involve some kind of anti-Semitic charge against those who don't subscribe to the premillennialist model.
So, as long as you want to steer it that way, let me just say that adhering to a theology that denies the fullness of Christ's sacrifice on the cross sounds a bit anti-Christian to me.