[al_c]

Good. Since the biblical evidence is essentional you shouldn't be oppossed to showing us some biblical evidence to support Perpetual Virginity and assumption and stuff like that.

Sacred Tradition, Steven. Perhpas you've heard of that? ;o)

There's nothing, traditionally or biblically, that supports that oddball theory of Jesus not being of Mary's egg. Without dodging or changing the subject, do you agree or disagree?

[Invincibly Ignorant]

Sacred Tradition, Steven. Perhpas you've heard of that? ;o)

Heard of it, yes. Some of us believe, however, that parts of human tradition are false. And so what are we left with? Scripture of course. And then when you ask for biblical evidence but can't produce it yourself the "sacred tradition" wildcard doesn't work.

There's nothing, traditionally or biblically, that supports that oddball theory of Jesus not being of Mary's egg. Without dodging or changing the subject, do you agree or disagree?

I never said there was. We were discussing Wonk's motives. Has nothing to do with whether or not I agree with the "egg" thing.