You're glossing over a lot in your reading of this thread. That much is clear.
Note that on that old thread linked in 308 I did not merely sneer at medved's inadequate response, but came back to it and dissected it in detail. This is exactly the scrutiny he's claiming his posts have never never never been given. They get it every time. Why on earth would they? How much real attention do you give to an advertising flyer in your mailbox if it's the same thing every other day for the last three weeks? But periodically, everybody gives him a look-over.
Anyone who takes any trouble knocks him out of the park. You don't have to be a genius. You just have to be sane.
Intended to say they don't get it every time but my slow modem connection ate one of the words or maybe it was my cat.
A typical example of Reep dissecting one of my posts in detail may be seen here starting around post 203. It begins with this same sort of bellicose claim to have destroyed my case a year earlier, and ends up with Reep's position shattered, his source exposed as a total ignoramus, and Reep inviting lurkers to view a talk.origins smear sheet describing me as a kook or something and crying "Well, I may be full of $#!T, but it doesn't matter cause the other guy's an A$$#OLE!!"
You thoght I would have forgotten about that after a couple of days, Reep?