[MHGinTN]

Perhaps we have found the source for your reasoning errors: MurphsLaw: "We are not spirits... we are not in a spiritual realm.... we are in the flesh until we die, until our Resurrected bodies are in Christ."

Murph, we are a spirit, a soul, and a body. WE ARE A SPIRIT before we are redeemed and after. The difference is that our spirit is dead in trespasses and sins until we are born again. There is an aspect of each of us which is already existing in that spiritual realm you are avoiding. Some are existing in a state of deadness spiritually but nevertheless existing in that spiritual realm. Some -both living and dead bodily- are alive in spirit in that spiritual realm. I have to go put drops in my eyes to continue ... hope I can hold my tarin of thought. Be back in a minute.

[MHGinTN]

Has it ever occurred to you that your claim of eating the soul and deity of Jesus does not work with your denial of our spiritual realm current existence? The flawed reasoning is scattered all through catholicism, like this error: you claim you can eat the soul and divinity -that is spirit, Murph- but are denying we are spiritual beings while we are in the physical body!

[SouthernClaire]

“Perhaps we have found the source for your reasoning errors: MurphsLaw: ‘We are not spirits... we are not in a spiritual realm.... we are in the flesh until we die, until our Resurrected bodies are in Christ.’”

BINGO.