[metmom]

And you’re referencing the Protoevangelium to back your claim up????????

What a hoot.

But that really doesn’t answer the question.

Why is it such a problem for Catholicism and Catholics if Mary had sex with Joseph and Jesus had half brothers and sisters through Mary as a result?

[MurphsLaw]

Why is it such a problem for Catholicism and Catholics if Mary had sex with Joseph and Jesus had half brothers and sisters through Mary as a result?

Why is it such a problem for those who , ok dismiss Mary being visited by an Angel SENT BY GOD- like that is happening all the time.....but have such a hard time understanding that Joseph- WHO WAS MUCH OLDER and would absolutety could have had children from a previous marriage. Show me in the Bible where it says Joseph couldn’t have children from a first marriage......

+++” For whoever does the will of My Father who is in heaven, he is My brother and sister and mother."+++