Seven Steps for United Methodism's Future (Reversing the Huge Membership Slide)

Christian Post ^ | 02/27/2018 | Mark D. Tooley

[SeekAndFind]

The United Methodist Church's Council of Bishops is meeting this week and again in April to consider proposals from the special commission on denominational controversies about homosexuality. That commission meets one more time in March to finalize its ideas for consideration by a specially scheduled General Conference in 2019.

Meanwhile, new membership statistics show USA United Methodism slumping below seven million members for the first time in 100 years, while globally the church is at a record 12.5 million members, thanks to church growth in Africa. The emerging new majority in Africa has prevented United Methodism, uniquely among historically liberal Mainline Protestant denominations, from liberalizing its marriage teaching, defined in church law as union of man and woman.

Here are my suggested essential principles for United Methodism's future:

1. Keep and Explain Marriage Teaching

United Methodism must retain its biblical stance on marriage and sexuality, which represents the ecumenical consensus of the faithful dating to the apostles. Any liberalization or localization of this teaching would create schism and accelerated membership implosion, as it has in every other denomination globally that has done so. It should be noted that the areas of greatest dissent from this teaching are the church's fastest declining regions, despite rhetoric about open doors. The historic church's rich understanding of marriage as union of man and woman, in cosmic relation to the eternal wedding feast uniting Christ and His church, must be better explained theologically as should a practical and faithful Wesleyan theology of the human body.

2. Don't Localize the Sexuality Battle

Denominational battles over sexuality, largely confined to the quadrennial General Conference or local annual conferences, should not be injected into the local church. Any plan forcing thousands of congregations to vote and choose sides would be calamitously divisive and destructive. USA United Methodism has over 30,000 local churches, and few of them are entirely conservative or liberal. Very few congregations have had formal conversations about the denominational controversy, and they are unprepared for suddenly confronting it.

3. Let Dissidents Leave

Hundreds of congregations, perhaps representing two percent of total USA churches and less than one percent of members, have openly dissented from the church's marriage teaching. They should be permitted to leave the denomination with their property and assets. So too should other and wider entities, including regions and schools. The church's Western Jurisdiction, which has illegally elected an actively lesbian bishop, and has two percent of total church membership, should be permitted to leave United Methodism, with its more orthodox local churches allowed to remain United Methodist. Its departure likely would include seminaries like Claremont in California and Iliff in Colorado, among others.

4. Fairness for Africa

United Methodism in Africa, with over 5.3 million members and 43 percent of total church membership, needs fairer representation in church governance. Too many church agencies and committees are led and staffed by USA persons, often from the most liberal and fastest declining regions. The General Board of Church and Society, for example, on its over 60 member board of directors, typically has only two or three Africans. Justice and reality require that exclusion of Africans must end. Church governance that looks more like the global church will be fairer and more effective.

5. Reach Beyond Older Whites

Our denomination in America is almost entirely white, older, middle and upper middle class, based in suburbs or small towns. United Methodism's future vitality requires special evangelistic outreach to non-whites, immigrants, millennials and urbanites. Christianity in America among all these groups is thriving but United Methodism largely is not participating. Official church structures for the foreseeable future are likely incapable of such outreach, which means local churches and other entrepreneurial initiatives must fill the void.

6. Rediscover Wesleyan Riches

There must be enhanced catechesis and discipleship for church membership based on Wesleyan distinctives. Denominational traditions are dying in America in favor of nondenominational Christianity. Methodism's future requires renewed appreciation for the theological richness of our own tradition rooted in the universal church, including liturgy, sacraments, and ecclesial connectionalism, sustained by the insights of John Wesley, the Reformers and Church Fathers. This renewal of Methodist doctrine and practice requires enhanced doctrinal education for and accountability by clergy, including bishops especially. And the church's seminaries must enter into a new relation of mutual accountability with the whole church.

7. Globalize Further

Soon a majority of United Methodists will be in Africa, for which we thank God. But our church should be more comprehensively global. United Methodism in America has declined for over 50 years and is moribund in Europe and the Philippines. New church plants are thriving in Southeast Asia, particularly Vietnam and Cambodia. There should be enhanced missions support for nascent United Methodism in Asia. Some day we pray its numbers and strength will equal Africa. We also as United Methodists must be in greater solidarity with the persecuted church in Asia, Africa and elsewhere. Their suffering should be ours, just as it is Christ's.

Originally posted at Juicy Ecumenism.

Mark Tooley became president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy (IRD) in 2009. He joined IRD in 1994 to found its United Methodist committee (UMAction). He is also editor of IRD's foreign policy and national security journal, Providence.

[fwdude]

What a joke. The carcass is full of maggots. How can it be revived?

There is no practical way to reverse the ordination of women (a core facilitator of the slide.) This is one of the things that cannot be undone.

Count the loss and move to a biblical denomination.

[TallahasseeConservative]

As a former Methodist seminarian who was basically forced out of the program due to being a “Theological Conservative”, Tooley is spot on. The problem is, it will never happen. As long as the UMC, has Bishops and District Superintendents who ignore the Book of Discipline, the slide will continue.

[FiddlePig]

Plan to stop membership slide... PREACH THE GOSPEL!!! That starts by firing Karl Marx.

[ontap]

I think the saying is “You Reap What You Sow”

[Theodore R.]

Aren’t Methodists long-term proponents of organized abortion? Are there some conservatives who oppose abortion still in the ranks? Wonder why they don’t leave the liberal enclave

[PGR88]

You can’t “market” your way out of this.

Either you are promoting the salvation of Christ to individuals to transform their moral behavior, or you are simply another vessel for the promotion of post-modern, neo-marxist, worldly politics.

[RightGeek]

[HamiltonJay]

I think one of the methodists bigger problems is they so fear dissent that they move ministers every 2 to 3 years.... So even if you get a good one, and they start to turn a church around.... POOF they are gone and replaced by someone else.....

All churches in the US are facing the same issues about membership and decline.... but the Methodists are making it doubly hard on themselves, by shifting leadership ever few years in local churches to make sure no one ever gets too loved and connected to their congregations.

[Maverick68]

They should learn the first rule of holes: stop digging.

[Preston Manning]

This article may just as well have been written about the United Church of Canada.

The United Church of Canada started out with the admirable goal of uniting the various “flavors” of Presbyterianism and Methodism that were largely splintered along ethnic/cultural lines when Canada was still a young country, emphasizing unity in the essentials of doctrine and grace in non-essentials of practice and preference.

Now it’s not even recognizable as “Christian” and is pretty much just the “Spiritual” wing of the NDP.

[robroys woman]

I think they could begin a program to really get things back together. They could focus on:

Worship
Teaching
Friendship.

It would be the WTF program.

[Buckeye McFrog]

I don’t see how they intend to hold to Biblical teachings on marriage and sexuality, and at the same time tell local congregations not to take sides or be drawn into the fray.
Those two things are mutually exclusive.

[SoConPubbie]

How about getting back to the business of solely preaching the Gospel as your founder John Wesley did??!!

[silverleaf]

Divestment from Israel
https://www.breakingisraelnews.com/58877/in-rejection-of-genesis-123-methodist-church-divests-from-israel-biblical-zionism/#/

Ordination of homosexuals who even live together in the parsonages

Apologia for abortion
http://www.lifenews.com/2012/06/11/united-methodist-church-continues-its-pro-abortion-ways/

Global warming religionists

I did not leave this church
It left me

[bmwcyle]

I left my Methodist church because I kept hearing Christians need to come out their comfort zone. They proved to me they would not discuss the topic of Giants of Genesis, The book of Enoch, or a timeline before the flood. I left.

[sphinx]

Hundreds of congregations, perhaps representing two percent of total USA churches and less than one percent of members, have openly dissented from the church's marriage teaching. They should be permitted to leave the denomination with their property and assets.

This is the key, and the principle needs to apply both ways. Move to a congregational model in which local churches own their own buildings, call their own pastors and support central church organizations (including colleges and seminaries) through voluntary assessments. Be clear as a matter of organizational principle and consistent practice that congregations are sovereign and can leave at any time. Problem solved.

Control over the seminaries is crucial. Traditionalist congregations, probably the majority among the Methodist churches, need a reliable supply of trustworthy pastors. My uninformed guess is that Methodism's current seminaries are not exactly hotbeds of orthodoxy.

[RoadieFan]

The Methodist church lost me when it stop following the bible

[RoadieFan]

All churches in the US are facing the same issues about membership and decline

Actually, that isn’t true. Evangelical churches that follow the bible closely, are seeing a rise in membership. Our church is now building it’s 3rd campus. We will hold Sunday services at 3 different locations, 3 services each. And no, we are not a mega church.

[SeekAndFind]

How about the college and universities that near the Methodist name? You know, Wesleyan and Southern Methodist come to mind....

What about the hospitals?