And I resent your derogation of the TLM by referring to it as “SSPX type”. It just verifies my suspicions that despite your screen name, you're a modernist.
ebb tide:
You are making inferences that are incorrect. I have no problem with the Tridentine Form of the Roman Rite. I think when it is done with Chant, it is a most reverent and beautiful Liturgy. I think the Normal Roman Rite is too simple and lacks the elegance of the Older Roman Rite and some of the Eastern Liturgies. However, I do not believe it is an invalid Rite.
I go to a Novo Ordo Roman Rite parish that incorporated traditional Greek (Kyrie) and Latin Chants (Agnus Dei, Gloria) and chants the Propers for the day, both entrance and communion.
In no post did I make derogatory statements regarding the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite. You are factually incorrect.
My comparison was an implicit one, as I said, not direct, that they are not inconsistent with each other.