[aMorePerfectUnion]

They can call themselves peach cobbler if they want, but that doesn’t make it so.

Except they are Catholics forever, according to FRomans.

So they can call themselves Catholics.

And you can choose not to like it or call them peach cobbler. Everyone is happy.

[dsc]

“Except they are Catholics forever, according to FRomans. So they can call themselves Catholics.”

The issue is not whether these heretics are Catholics, as individual people. The issue is whether they are a Roman Catholic church.

There are requirements for forming and operating a Roman Catholic Church. These clowns don’t even begin to meet these requirements, by several country miles.

You should make an effort to argue honestly.