Replies

Your definition of a true Catholic is as legalistic as the unending geneologies in the Old Testament. In St. Paul's Letter to the Romans 8 & 9, St. Paul corrects those who believe that there physical geneology as a Jew is what makes them acceptable to God. St. Paul says that the true believers are not physical sons of Abraham but spiritual children of Abraham. Please see Romans 9:7 & 8. We as Catholics are spiritual children of Abraham, in other words, children of the Promise, and the Promise is Christ. Any Catholic with a Baptismal Certificate can register in any parish on the Earth. It would then be assumed that they are subjects of the Roman Pontiff. They may be atheists, Freemasons, whoremongers, active homosexuals, communists, or sede vacantis (Which I am not). None of your criteria will guarantee a good Catholic. In Romans 9:27, St. Paul, quoting Isaiah, in verses 27~29, says as much. A remnant is a small piece of the original.

The much maligned Pope St. John Paul II imitated and understood Abraham in how he sought after the hearts of non Catholics and Catholics alike trying as Jesus did to adopt them as His Spiritual Children. (The One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church teaches us that our Baptism is in reality Jesus adopting us as part of His family.) My heart, as I believe Pope St. John Paul II's heart was, is with the teachings of The One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church pre-Fatima, and I, like Abraham, in Hebrews 11, am not looking for and earthly city (Rome) but rather..."a city that has foundations; whose Builder and Maker is God." (Verse 10) As In Hebrews 11:16, Like Abraham..."I desire a better, that is to say, a Heavenly Country." Therefore, having God not be ashamed to be called my God for He has prepared for me a city. Jesus never taught legalism but rather what is in each person's heart in saying that what's in a man's heart will soon come out of his mouth. My heart is with Christ and I am joined, through the Scriptures, and my Baptism, as part of His True Spiritual Church. I could never consider Pope St. John Paul II as I do if my heart were otherwise as I believe him to be the father Abraham of our times. I also believe that he will return to us along with St. John, the Apostle (see Apocalypse 10:8~11) as one of the two Witnesses in Apocalypse 11. I believe he's in the same place as is St. John the Apostle, having been translated and being still in touch with their bodies. I believe that it is through him that the channel of Grace still flows between God and His Church. Therefore, he is the Pope of the Remnant Church and therefore my Pope. I may not pass your muster/qualifications, but then my concern is truly to pass God's muster/qualifications as I have been taught them as a traditional Catholic.