[jafojeffsurf]

Fatima the Miracle of the Sun. Sermon on the Fact of this Miracle.

Those who reject Fact Reject Truth, Those that Reject Truth Reject God.

Seek the Truth for the Truth Shall Set You Free!

http://www.romans10seventeen.org/audio-files/20120513-Fatima-The-Miracle-of-the-Sun.mp3

[ealgeone]

Mrs. d says this is private revelation and no one is under obligation to believe it. You seem to suggest it is truth and is to be believed as fact. You both can’t be right. How ever you both can be wrong.

[Mrs. Don-o]

Logically, this is the kind of direct contradiction (A/ non-A) where one is right and one is wrong. We can't both be wrong, because it can't be both oligatory, and non-obligatory, to believe private revelation: not at the same time, and not in the same manner.

The Catholic Catechism, para 67 (LINK) says private revelation "does not belong to the deposit of faith."