It's coming from "opposite-land" --where part of what you say, refutes other assertions.
I could explain how that is, break it down step-by-step,but it would tedious, and tend to make the thread be about people rather than about perspectives, and vast arrays of data.
Try discussing the data itself (or not) and not delve into analysis of persons here, including allusions to, and speculations towards their motivations --when they offer, or point towards "arrays of data".
Unless you would care to open this up to each being treated the same, operating under the same rules you do, thus yourself become subject of off-hand commentary regarding your own self and motivations, instead of whatever subject matter was under discussion?
Then again, that would go against the rules of this forum. We can't have that, now can we?
If you're saying that the Protestant vs Catholic thing works for you, then have at it. I'm just saying that I don't get it and that it seems like a very bad idea.
Lowly sinner that I am and never the smartest guy in any room, all I have is my perspective and that's all I'm offering.
As far as the PvC family feud is concerned, I'm saying with me "there's no war here unless you've brought it with you."
I'm just another believer looking for clues, gathering data, pondering His Mysteries, and trying to work through my theories on how all of this data fits together so I can makes sense of it.
For example, Mother Mary is one of those Mysteries, too, and there is quite a lot of Mother Mary data to sort through and account for and understand.
That's where I'm at these days. I prayed for Him to reveal Himself to me and that's what He did, right when I needed Him the most.
And now my life has never been better!