You said ALL of the ECFs were in agreement on this. ALL means 100%.
Consensus doesn’t fall from the skies. There is discussion and debate. In the end under Petrine authority the early Church fathers, as the link provided you so exhaustively explains, affirmatively held to this belief and it is so today to the point that leading non-Catholic theologians and scholars have accepted this doctrine and enthusiastically converted to the Catholic Church. This is no longer a matter of debate except among those who fear to do so since their livelihood (think Joel Osteen etc) will be threatened.