“- God created all of us; He could not possibly become one of us.” I am astonished that you would even try to make that syllogism.
Why did you not include the third part of the statement, (But He did.)
This is what is truly astonishing, that Jesus, being in the form of God, would come in human likeness.
You wrote and it astonished me, "God created all of us; He could not possibly become one of us" Are you unable to see how you have constructed a straw man so you can topple it? is that the best reasoning you are capable of? ... If so, we really will never be able to have a coherent conversation. Do you know what a 'straw man' is?