[xone]

To claim that that proves "sola Scriptura" is like claiming that because nutritionists say broccoli is good for you, you should eat nothing but broccoli.

What you say might be valid, when nutritionists' outlook is on par with God's Word.

[papertyger]

What you say might be valid, when nutritionists' outlook is on par with God's Word.

So how does God's outlook differ from the nutritionist that makes something you admit should be valid?

[maryz]

What you say might be valid, when nutritionists' outlook is on par with God's Word.

The logical principle holds. It has nothing to do with setting up some kind of straw man pretending that I've somehow equated nutritionists with God.