I don’t think that we ever had the choice to not sin until we became born again.
We were born into sin and have a sin nature that is natural to us. Therefore we sin, because we have a sin nature that we inherited from Adam.
...”We were born into sin and have a sin nature that is natural to us. Therefore we sin, because we have a sin nature that we inherited from Adam”...
That’s us since Adam....but what were the natures of Adam and Eve before they sinned? They could not have had the nature we contend with unitl afterward......