[ealgeone]

>>Recall that Paul had to correct Peter. Not a good claim to Peter being the rock.<<

Not quite true, Paul told the Galatians about such an incident.

Are you saying that Paul did not correct Peter face to face over Peter's withdrawal from the Gentiles??

[ravenwolf]

Are you saying that Paul did not correct Peter face to face over Peter’s withdrawal from the Gentiles??

---

He told the Galatians he with stood Peter face to face because Peter was wrong.

There is nothing recorded in acts of this happening, meaning no witnesses.

The anti Catholic`s want to see more proof other than what Jesus provided about Peter being the rock.

But what ever Paul says is the Gospel.

Something not quite right.