[verga]

Actually you are the only one presuming: Exactly! We already know the question was asked dishonestly because if we said, yes, we would be called liars or “poorly catechized”. If we answered no, we would be told, “See, we don’t, case closed!”. Some Catholics show a surprising lack of integrity and it comes out in how they speak to others.

You presumed to know that my response would be to your answer.

The fact that neither of you chose to give a legitimate answer to simple yes or no questions speaks volumes.

[boatbums]

It's not presumption when you have the proof already thrown at you countless times. Since you're showing all this concern about integrity, can you go ahead and demonstrate what you would have replied if the answer was simply "yes" or "no"?

The fact that you chose to ask a question that you certainly SHOULD have known was not a simple yes or no one, shows who is the one speaking volumes here? Gotcha questions are tricks of those who have an agenda and who really have no interest in honest answers.