Exactly! We already know the question was asked dishonestly because if we said, yes, we would be called liars or “poorly catechized”. If we answered no, we would be told, “See, we don’t, case closed!”. Some Catholics show a surprising lack of integrity and it comes out in how they speak to others.
Incorrect. It was asked to see if ex-Catholics /anti-Catholics have integrity or are capable of telling the truth.
The answer is a resounding NO!