[metmom]

Some Protestants think “If a person could be saved without this, it must be false.”

On what planet?

A person can be saved without being baptized, but nobody ever said that baptism is *false*.

The teaching that baptism is required is a false teaching, however.

[dsc]

“On what planet?”

Yours.

“A person can be saved without being baptized, but nobody ever said that baptism is *false*.”

You do, in your next sentence.

Besides, you can’t rebut the observed phenomenon with one cherry-picked instance.