Maybe you could dig your hole deeper by describing what it is that makes Catholics unfit?
Tell me why evangelical Protestants, who make up such a large share of the GOP and vote for it overwhelmingly, can’t have so much as one GOP picked SC justice? Why are Catholics much preferred instead? If evangelicals speak up, maybe it will then become 4-1 or 3-2 rather than 5-0. Why does it bother you that an evangelical Christian questions why Christians are entirely represented by Catholics on the SC and would like to change that? I’ve never said that all GOP-picked justices have to be evangelical and none can be Catholic. But such a shutout is what evangelicals have. Why doesn’t that concern you?
Given our form of government and Catholicism’s stated beliefs, I can accept some GOP-nominated Catholics. But without evangelical Christians in America, the country would be like Europe’s twin. More than anything else, the GOP base is evangelical Christian and we should be represented on the SC.