you can make the same claim about some protestant confessions that hold to strict double pre-destination, if you take it to its theological conclusion, then God predestined some men to do good and some do evil.
Muslims are not atheist, and they believe in God, they obviously misunderstand his nature [lack Trinitarian Doctrine and Christological view] and clearly have some misguided views of God.
that might be the theological understatement of the year....muslims have some misguided views of God.
muslims do not believe in God...they believe in Allah
they aren't the same in any sense.