T: this has to do with protecting people’s RIGHT to live THEIR religion as THEY SEE FIT.
Are you going to argue that a Muslim should serve pork at their restaurant? Are you going to tell them thay they are not being relistic, or approoriate as Muslims?
Y: Jews who own traditional Jewish delis (obviously not kosher delis) serve pork - there are blt sandwiches, bacon, etc. Do you want to only sell to people who are like you, or do you want everyone to eat at your place?
T: Yet you feel perfectly able to tell Christians the limits and standards of Christianity.
Y: Nope, never did I feel or say that.
This is about commerce and selling to the general public. Wedding cakes are cakes. They are not religious. I don’t have to know much about Christianity to know that wedding cakes are not religious, and also to know that sinners buy them. Sinners of all kinds.
Should a Protestant baker be forced by law to provide a Marian themed wedding cake to a Catholic couple? Should a Protestant photographer be forced by law to attend and photograph a Catholic Nuptial Mass?
I'm Catholic and I say no to both.