Replies

The Sabbath also preceded the law, being established in the days of creation and given to Israel before the giving of the law at Mt. Sinai (Exo. 16). It is a means of honoring and emulating the Creator. So why teach the tithe and not the Sabbath?

Not sure of your beliefs but yup, and it's prophesied to be observed in the future along with the feast days.

You're either messianic or Jewish correct?

Correct. While my own Jewish ancestry is muddled at best, my wife and therefore my children are fully Jewish (an orthodox rabbi was even willing to serve as my son's moyel on that basis). Back while we were still dating I basically pulled a Ruth and said to her, "Your people will be my people."

However, since all this took place in a Messianic synagogue rather than an Orthodox one, I accept the right of my people not to accept me as their person. I've been rather surprised and gratified at how many do, particularly among my wife's extended family, but my love for and commitment to the Jews is not dependent on that love ever being returned.

The end result is that after many years of studying the issues, I've decided to go with Romans 14 and not make a huge issue out of the Sabbaths and Feasts to Gentiles. If a Christian can give a cogent argument as to why they don't observe the "Jewish" feastdays from the Scripture, then I still regard them as my brother in the Messiah, striving to keep the commandments of God to the best of their understanding out of faith. I believe that Isaiah 56 contains a Divine invitation to those non-Jews who wish to partake in Jewish cultural life to do so, but that the NT clarifies this to be an invitation, not a compulsion.

The only reason I'm picking on the tithe is because for a Christian to insist on it does require an inconsistant hermeneutic.

However, I reject the forced (or even socially pressured) Gentilization of Jewish Christians as being every bit as much a false gospel as the forced Judaizing of Christians.

Hopefully not TMI, but I think it's best to be open and honest on these issues to avoid misunderstanding.

Shalom.