If the Saints are not alive and do not have eternal life then the Gospels are a lie. If there are not creatures who are 100% spirit then the Old and New Testaments are a lie. You can't have it both ways nor impose the limitations of your understandings on God.
“If the Saints are not alive and do not have eternal life then the Gospels are a lie.”
We aren’t talking about whether or not they have eternal life or are spirits. We’re talking about whether Christians after death have the divine qualities of omnipresence and omniscience, and take up the role of God in hearing and answering prayer.