I'm not confusing myself, I'm asking you a question.
When Mary gave birth to Jesus, was He only Human or was He divine? It's a simple question and a simple answer will suffice, if you have one.
You’re trying to get something eternal to be born, and that is fallacy.
Is it a fallacy that Jesus is divine? Is it a fallacy that Jesus was born?
What did Elizabeth mean when she asked: "And how has it happened to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?"
>> “It’s a simple question and a simple answer will suffice” <<
Its an ignorant question.
The son of God is an eternal being. what Mary bore was his connection to humanity, not his eternal divinity.
That’s the trouble with fallible oral traditions; they create this kind of foolishness. Stick with the word of God, not men’s traditions.